Information
Source Guide on:
“Hydrogen
Sulfide Gas- “ A Rotten Egg Odor”

Prepared by:
(Information Services Department)
National
Scientific &
Kuwait Institute for Scientific
Research
Hydrogen Sulfide (H2S) in Groundwater
Treatment and Control of Hydrogen Sulfide Odor
Impact of Hydrogen Sulfide on Health
HYDROGEN SULFIDE QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
SELECTED INTERNET SITES ON HYDROGEN SULFIDE
Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is a
colorless gas with a rotten-egg odor. Some people can smell hydrogen sulfide at
very low levels, as 0.5 parts per billion (ppb) in air. Most hydrogen sulfide
in the air comes from natural sources. It is produced when bacteria break down
plant and animal material, often in stagnant waters with low oxygen content
such as bogs and swamps. Volcanoes,
H2S is extremely toxic, and
is corrosive to metals such as iron, zinc, copper, lead and cadmium. It reacts
with water to form sulfuric acid that corrodes lead-based paint, concrete,
metals and sewer lines. (See cover page, the photograph show a sewer pipe
destroyed by corrosion).
This information source
guide on “ Hydrogen Sulfide Gas” focuses on latest studies conducted on H2S in
two main sources, groundwater and wastewater treatment plant. Information in
the guide is drawn from international databases, water resources database (file
117), Enviroline (file40) and MEDLINE
(file154). The information source guide is divided into three sections; (1)
annotated bibliography (2) questions and answers about Hydrogen sulfide, and
(3) selected Internet sites on H2S.
Taste and odour removal from an urban
groundwater establishment - a case study
Ortenberg, E ; Groisman, L ; Rav Acha, C
Water Science and Technology vol. 42, no.
1-2, pp. 123-128; 2000
Abstract: A deep groundwater well was established in a village
near Tel-Aviv, in order to supply drinking water for its 30,000 inhabitants.
Although all water characteristics were within the range permitted by the
Israeli regulations, operators received complaints about a funny taste and a
rotten-egg odour in the water. This was attributed to the presence of 0.38 mgL
super(-1) hydrogen sulfide. Removing the odour by the usual method of aeration
was impossible because of the populatedsurroundings. Therefore it was decided
to examine chemical oxidants for taste
and odour removal. A treatment with 8 mgL super(-1) of chlorine
successfully oxidized hydrogen sulfide but
the complaints continued. This was attributed to the formation of elemental
sulfur, which is converted into polysulfide that may hydrolyze to regenerate
the odourous hydrogen sulfide. Treatment with 2 mgL super(-1) of chlorine dioxide successfully eliminates odour
completely, but produces chlorite and
chlorate which are above the permitted levels. A partial solution to this
problem was found by a consequential treatment with 2 mgL super(-1) of ClO
sub(2) for 10 min. followed by 1.5 mgL super(-1) of chlorine (30 min.). In this case the
chlorite is reduced substantially to be
within the permitted level. In addition, such treatmentregenerates some of the
chlorine dioxide thereby increasing its
residual. The odourous H sub(2)S can also be eliminated with 3 mgL
super(-1) of ozone. Advantages and
disadvantages of the above treatments are discussed.
Microbial H sub(2) Cycling Does Not
Affect delta super(2)H Values of Ground
Water
Landmeyer, J E ; Chapelle, F H ; Bradley, P M
Ground Water vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 376-380,
2000
Abstract: Stable hydrogen-isotope values of ground water (
delta super(2)H) and dissolved hydrogen concentrations (H sub(2(aq))) were
quantified in a petroleum-hydrocarbon contaminated aquifer to determine whether the production/consumption of H
sub(2) by subsurface microorganisms affects ground water delta
super(2)H values. The range of
delta super(2)H observed in
monitoring wells sampled (-27.8 ppt to -15.5 ppt) was best explained, however,
by seasonal differences in recharge temperature as indicated using ground
water delta super(18)O values, rather than isotopic
exchange reactions involving the microbial cycling of H sub(2) during anaerobic
petroleum-hydrocarbon biodegradation. The absence of a measurable
hydrogen-isotope exchange between microbially cycled H sub(2) and ground water reflects
the fact that the amount of H sub(2) available from the anaerobic decomposition
of petroleum hydrocarbons is small relative to the amount of hydrogen present in water, even though milligram per
liter concentrations of readily biodegradable contaminants are present at the
study site.Additionally, isotopic fractionation calculations indicate that in
order for H sub(2) cycling processes to affect
delta super(2)H values of ground
water, relatively high concentrations of H sub(2) (>0.080 M)would have to be
maintained, considerably higher than the 0.2 to 26 nM present at this site and
characteristic of anaerobic conditions in general. These observations suggest
that the conventional approach of
using
delta super(2)H and delta
super(18)O values to determine recharge history is appropriate even for
those ground water systems characterized by anaerobic conditions and extensive
microbial H sub(2) cycling.
Distribution of sulfate and organic
carbon in a prairie till setting: Natural versus industrial sources
Fennell, J ; Bentley, L R
Water Resources Research vol. 34, no. 7, pp.
1781-1794, 1998
Biodegradation of sulfolane in soil and
groundwater samples from a sour gas plant site
Fedorak, P M ; Coy, D L
Dep.
Biol. Sci., Univ. Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E9, Canada
Environmental Technology vol. 17, no. 10, pp.
1093-1102; 1996
Abstract: Sulfolane is used as a solvent in processes for the
removal of Hsub(2)S from sour gas. Because of its high water-solubility, soil
contamination by sulfolane quickly leads to groundwater contamination.To assess
the possibility of using bioremediation to remove this
compound, samples of soils, groundwaters,
and sandstone from a contaminated
aquifer at a gas plant were used in laboratory studies to determine if they
contained sulfolane-degrading microbial populations. Aerobic shake-flask slurry cultures were
incubated at 26 degree and 8
degree C, and solid phase soil bioreactors,
approximating bioventing, were incubated
at 8 degree C to test sulfolane biodegradability. Each environmental sample
yielded microbial populations that degraded sulfolane. Supplementation with N
and P stimulated degradation. The most
rapid rates of degradation in slurry cultures incubated at 26 degree C and 8
degree C were 8 and 4 mg L super(-1) d super(-1),respectively. In the soil
column bioreactors supplemented with N and P,
the rates of sulfolane biodegradation were between 0.5 and 0.7 mg kg
super(-1) d super(-1).
Ground Water
Nelson, G
L ; Munter, J A
Cold Regions Hydrology and Hydraulics.
American Society of Civil Engineers, New York. 1990. p 317-348, 15 fig, 29
ref., 1990.
Abstract: Groundwater in cold regions differs from that in warm
regions, not by virtue of any changes in its adherence to physical laws of groundwater flow, but by its interaction with
frozen ground and freezing conditions in the surface environment. Permafrost,
which underlies about 85 percent of
Alaska, 50 percent of the Soviet Union and Canada, and 22 percent of China, is
a confining layer that transmits only
slight amounts of water. Movement of water occurs along thin films of liquid
water adsorbed on soil grains, even at
temperatures well below freezing. Groundwater is classified as
subpermafrost or suprapermafrost, depending on whether it is below or above the
permafrost. In the zone of continuous permafrost, suprapermafrost water is
available seasonally but is susceptible to
contamination. Subpermafrost water is expensive to develop and commonly brackish to saline, particularly in coastal
environments. Therefore, large springs
in limestone terrains are a major water resource in the Arctic. Taliks
underlying rivers do not contain flowing groundwater, and are not a major water supply except in
rivers such as the Mackenzie which
flow throughout the winter. Coastal communities in the Arctic also have
additional water supply problems caused by shallow salt water. In the zone of
discontinuous permafrost, communities near rivers generally have no problem
developing a water supply, although water commonly must be treated to remove
iron, manganese, methane, and hydrogen sulfide. Base flow in streams is a poor
indicator of aquifer properties because
much of the winter discharge of groundwater freezes and does not contribute to
base flow. The formation of icings in stream channels may cause high water
table conditions in the winter, when it
would not be expected. Water supply wells generally function well with
moderate frost protection. Observation wells, however, require additional work
to continually adjust to the frozen ground phenomenon termed 'frost jacking.'
Water quality in cold regions is commonly
affected by reducing conditions, high
concentrations of organics and reduced
microbial activity. Permafrost can be thawed either by removing insulating vegetation or by regional or
global climate warming, but the consequences on water supplies, waste disposal
activities, engineered structures, and biological habitats may be significant.
Quality of the Ground
Water around the Lower Reaches of
the Miya River
Sugiyama, M ; Fujii, K ; Maeda, H ; Maruyama,
T ; Kumada, H
Bulletin of National Research Institute of
Aquaculture YKHKDU No. 15, p 29-36,
1989. 2 fig, 1 tab, 15 ref. English summary. 1989.
Abstract: Since the establishment of the Inland station (Tamaki
campus) of the National Research
Institute of Aquaculture in 1979, the rearing
water for experimental fishes has been supplied by four artesian wells
in the campus. Prior to the establishment of the campus, assessment of the quality of groundwater around the campus
had been done in 1973 and 1974. The
quality of the artesian well water were reassessed in March of 1987, in order
to examine changes in the quality with the passage of years. The levels of ammonium nitrogen,
nitrite nitrogen, hydrogen sulfide, and manganese which are toxic to fish were
below the level
that is detrimental to fish health. The
levels of total iron in the well water in 1987 were slightly higher than those
in 1974. The increase in iron levels may be caused by rust release from pumping
equipment submerged in each well. The present results indicate that, in spite of the increase in the pumped volume of
groundwater around the Tamaki campus, the quality of artesian well water in the
campus is almost unchanged compared with those in 1974, and that the water
is suitable for fish culture. (Author 's
abstract)
Distribution and Source of Barium in Ground
Water , Cattaraugus Indian
Reservation, Southwestern New York
Moore, R B ; Staubitz, W W
Water-Resources Investigations Report
84-4129, 1984. 17 p, 4 fig, 4 tab, 15
ref.
Abstract: High concentrations of dissolved barium have been
found in ground water from bedrock wells on the Seneca Nation of Indians
Reservation on Cattaraugus Creek in southwestern New York.Concentrations in
1982 were as high as 23.0 milligrams per liter , the
highest found reported from any natural
ground-water system in the world. The
highest concentrations are in a bedrock aquifer and in small lenses of
saturated gravel between bedrock and the overlying till. The bedrock aquifer is partly confined by silt,
clay, and till. The high barium
concentrations are attributed to dissolution of the mineral barite (BaSO4), which is present in the
bedrock and possibly in overlying silt, clay, or till. The dissolution of
barite seems to be controlled by action
of sulfate-reducing bacteria, which alter the BaSO4 equilibrium by removing
sulfate ions and permitting additional barite to dissolve. Ground water from
the surficial, unconsolidated deposits and surface water in streams contain
little or no barium. Because barium is chemically similar to calcium, it
probably could be removed by cation exchange or treatments similar to those
used for water softening.
Ground - Water Geochemistry: Arsenic in
Landfills
Hounslow, A W
Ground Water Vol 18, No 4, p 331-333,
July/August, 1980. 1 Fig, 10 Ref. 1980
Abstract: Arsenic leaking from landfills commonly exists in +3
(arsenite) and +5 (arsenate) valence states, depending on the
oxidation-reduction state of the groundwater and the presence of iron. Arsenite
ion is 60 times as toxic to humans as arsenate ion. Three types of aqueous
environments may be described: aerobic--dissolved oxygen present, hydrogen
sulfide absent, unsaturated zone present, arsenate soluble, ferric hydroxide
insoluble, arsenate adsorbed
anaerobic--dissolved oxygen absent , hydrogen sulfide absent, mildly
reducing, shallow groundwater, arsenite soluble ferrous iron soluble
anaerobic--dissolved oxygen absent, hydrogen sulfide present, deeper groundwater,
arsenic sulfides insoluble, heavy metal sulfarsenites insoluble, iron sulfide
insoluble, coprecipitated arsenic sulfides. The most likely environmental pollution source
is the mildly reducing anaerobic water, in which iron and toxic arsenite are
most prevalent and most mobile.
Chemical Quality of Ground
Water on Cape Cod, Massachusetts
Frimpter, M H ; Gay, F B
Geological Survey Water-Resources
Investigations 79-65 (open-file report) 1979. 11 p, 6 Fig, 2 Plates, 2 Tab, 9
Ref.1979
Abstract: Cape Cod is a 440 square mile hook-shaped peninsula,
which extends 40 miles into the Atlantic. Freshwater in Pleistocene sand and
gravel deposits is the source of supply for nearly 100 municipal and thousands
of private domestic wells. Most ground water on Cape Cod is of good chemical
quality for drinking and other uses. It is characteristically low in dissolved
solids and is soft. In 90 percent of the samples analyzed, dissolved solids
were less than 100 mg/l(milligrams per liter) and pH was less than 7.0. Highway
deicing salt, sea-water flooding due to storms, and saltwater intrusion due to
ground-water withdrawal are sources of sodium chloride contamination.Chloride
concentrations have increased from 20 to 140 mg/l, owing to saltwater intrusion
at Provincetown 's wells in Truro. In Yarmouth, contaminated ground water near a
salt-storage area contained as much as 1,800 mg/l chloride. Heavy metals,
insecticides, and herbicides were not found at concentrations above the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency 's recommended limits for public drinking-water
supplies, but iron and manganese in some samples exceeded those limits. Ninety
percent of 84 samples analyzed for nitrate reported as nitrogencontained less
than 1.3 mg/l and 80 percent contained 0.5 mg/l or less of nitrate as nitrogen.
Water containing nitrogen in excess of 0.5 mg/l
has probably been affected by municipal or domestic sewage or
fertilizer, and water with less than this amount may have been affected by
them.
Obstacles to Geothermal Development
Budiansky, S P
Environmental Science and Technology Vol 14,
No 3, p 255-257, March, 1980. 1 Fig.
Abstract: Legal, financial, and environmental problems
associated withgeothermal development are minor compared with problems
associated with the development of other energy resources. However, these
problems must be solved if delays are to be avoided. Direct use of geothermal
energy, unlike high-temperature applications, does not cause air pollution but
can result in water pollution. The use of injection wells can minimize ground
water pollution, water table lowering and land subsidence. The deterioration of
ground water quality surrounding an injection well over a 30 year period has
been simulated by researchers at EG and GIdaho. Direct use applications are
also faced with laws and regulations which were based on the concept of
high-temperature,electric-generating, and revenue producing resources. These
laws do not apply to low-temperature resources. With some modification,
existing water law can provide the basis
for direct use development. For example, geoheating would be classified as '
reasonable use ' of water resources, and
appropriate rights over the entire volume of the resource should not be required for closed
systems which return the water they use.
The Effect of Organic Carbon on the
Concentrations of Iron and Hydrogen Sulfide
in Ground Water
Stoufer, R N
1975
NOTES: Available from the National Technical
Information Service, Springfield VA 22161 as PB-291 555, Price codes: A05 in
paper copy, A01 in microfiche. M. A. thesis December 1975. 85 p, 18 fig, 10
tab, 54 ref, append. OWRT B-077-MO(3), 14-31-0001-3608.
Abstract: Twenty water supply wells in northern Missouri were
sampled to determine the relationships between dissolved organic carbon and
microorganisms on iron and sulfide concentrations in unpolluted ground water.
The concentrations of ferrous iron, sulfide, organic carbon, major ions and the
pH and Eh were determined on each water sample. Organic carbon and dissolved ferrous iron
were readily measurable in samples. Organic carbon was generally present at low
levels (2 mg/l). Even though thee was no evidence of coliform or streptococcus
microorganisms none of the water samples was sterile. Two to six generaof non-pathogenic
bacteria were present in each sample, the majority being nitrate reducers.
Sulfate-reducing bacteria were detected in half of the samples. The data
suggest that there is a poor correlationbetween the redox potential and
dissolved organic carbon in ground water. The organic carbon content of the
rocks appears to be a more important factor in controlling the redox potential
of ground water.The data for nitrate-ammonia and sulfate-sulfide indicate that
many ofthe water samples were not in internal equilibrium with respect to oxidation-reduction reactions.
Ground Water Resources of the Bedrock
Aquifers of the Denver Basin Colorado
Romero, J C
1976. p 109 12 plates, 28 fig, 7 tab, 66
ref, 2 append.
Abstract: The bedrock aquifers of the Denver Basin contain vast
quantities of groundwater suitable, in most localities, for all beneficial
purposes. The major problems which will confront both administrators and users
of this groundwater include those associated with declining water levels and
deterioration of water quality. Areas in which current water level declines are
rapid enough to cause concern are the South Platte River corridor, the
Strasburg-Byers-Deer Trail area, and parts of metropolitan Denver. Water
quality problems of the Denver Basin 's bedrock aquifers are confined
predominantly to the Laramie Formation and Laramie-Fox Hill aquifer. Water from
these units is locally known to contain troublesome amounts of hydrogen
sulfide, methane, iron, floride and sodium. Many of these problems can probably
be eliminated by avoiding multi-aquifer completions, particularly in the case
of mixing Laramie-Fox Hill aquifer water with Dawson Group water. Successful
management of the Denver Basin bedrock aquifers will require the collection and
utilization of additional data. The importance of additional electric logs,
geologic sample logs and aquifer test data cannot be over-emphasized. Also of
major importance are water quality testing, an observation well network and
accurate measurements of water withdrawn from the aquifer. If managed with
caution, the basin can supply the water needs of several generations.
Ground Water Supplies Of Northeastern
Illinois -- Quality Problems With Well Waters
Larson, T E
Journal American Water Works Association,
VOL 56, NO 2, P 169-172, February 1964.
Abstract: most problems in well water quality are inherent and
not Receptive to correction by any means
other than external treatment.These problems are usually related to the natural
hardness or iron Content of the water
from the aquifer or from one of the contributing Aquifers. Perhaps the most annoying
problems are due to the iron Content of
the water. At times the occurrence of such problems is Inexcusable or may be condoned only because
of lack of information or Adequate interpretation
of information. Another less frequently Encountered but more objectionable
problem is that of hydrogen sulfide In
well waters. This 'rotten-egg' odor almost always demands treatment. Case
studies of these problems, their causes and corrective measures taken in 3
aquifers are presented. It is concluded that in many cases the pollutants enter
the well from outside the producing zone due to
improper or nonexistent sealing
however, it should be remembered that
preventive measures taken during construction are usually superior
to and less costly than corrective
measures.
Gas in Ground Water
Journal of the American Water Works
Association, Vol 61, No 8, P 413-414, August, 1969.
Abstract: a summary of gas characteristics in ground water is given
in order to acquaint water utilities employees and others with its nature,
origins, and hazards. both methane and hydrogen sulfide are commonflammable
gases found in ground water, the latter being less dangerous because it has a
distinctive odor. Examples of isolated explosions attributed to gas in ground
water occurring in Michigan and New York State, as well as a possible one in
Louisiana, are mentioned. The inimum concentration of methane in water
sufficient to produce an explosive methane-air mixture (5-15 per cent methane
in a gas-air mixture) above
the water from which it evolves can be as
little as 1.1 ppm at normal conditions, in poorly ventilated air spaces. Under
these conditions explosions can occur in shower stalls, water treatment plants,
storage reservoirs, water tanks, and other poorly ventilated air spaces.
Suffocation is another hazard of gas in ground waters. Safety measures for
decreasing the hazards include aeration of the water before use, and adequate
ventilation of air spaces around the
well in places where the water is to be used.
Spectrophotometric Microdetermination of
Sulfate
Davis, j b ; lindstrom, f
Analytical chemistry, vol. 44, no. 3, p 524-532, March 1972. 11
fig, 1 Tab, 22 ref.
Abstract: sulfate reduction to hydrogen sulfide is the basis
for the Spectrophotometric method which has been developed for the selective
Determination of sulfate in the 0-10 and 0-100 microgram (ppm in water) Ranges.
Aqueous sampl Es are treated with a mixture of hydriodic acid, Acetic anhydride,
and sodium hypophosphite and heated in a modified Countercurrent reaction
apparatus to evolve hydrogen sulfide. The gas Is swept by nitrogen into a
buffered solution of a ferric Ion and 1,10-phenanthroline, where it reduces the
ferric ion to the ferrous Ion. A bright orange tris (1,10-phenanthroline - iron
ii) complex forms And is measured spectrophotometrically at 510 nm. Over twenty
common Ions and three sulfonated surfactants were tested to
determineInterference. Only nitrite and those ions capable of yielding hydrogen
Sulfide under the same conditions interfered while the sulfonated Surfactants
did not interfere.
Ground water for planning in northwest
Ohio, a study of the carbonate Rock aquifers
Ohio
Dept. Of Natural Resources, Columbus. Div. Of Water 1970. 123 P, 73 Fig, 10
Tab, 30 Ref.
Abstract: the northwest Ohio water development plan, prepared
by the Ohio water commission (1967), recommended a drilling and testing program
to evaluate the quantity and quality of
the ground water available in the
northwest Ohio area. seventy-six large diameter limestone and dolomite
wells were drilled, tested, and analyzed as the basis for this two and one-half year study. the limestone-dolomite
aquifer in northwest Ohio currently
yields 32.69 million gallons per day to municipal andindustrial wells. large
additional quantities are pumped for irrigation and domestic supplies.
estimates of well-field capacities in various undeveloped areas have been
included in this report as a guide for potential development. the quality of
the ground water is equally as important
as quantity in planning for future use. softening is recommended for ground-water supplies
throughout the study area. hydrogen
sulfide is often present in varying amounts. however, in nearly all instances,
objectionable concentrations of hydrogen sulfidecan be removed by simple and
inexpensive processes. ground-water
development in some portions of the area would be restricted by quality considerations, with present treatment
methods. even considering the quality limitations, the potential of the
carbonate aquifer in northwest ohio far exceeds the present ground-water
development.
Removal of H2S by
Metal Ferrites Produced in the Purification of Metal-Bearing Waste
Water . Study of the Reaction Mechanism
Barrado, E ; Prieto, F ; Lozano, B ; Arenas, F
J ; Medina, J
Water, Air, and Soil
Pollution vol. 131, no. 1-4, pp. 367-381, 2001
Abstract: Waste water polluted with heavy metals can be
successfully purified by precipitation of the metals from an alkaline solution
containing iron (II), giving rise to a ferrite sludge. The solid metal ferrites
obtained in this manner can be used to remove hydrogen sulphide from a gas
stream. Based on a Taguchi experimental design,ferrite solid particle and pore
size, and the temperature resulting in maximum retention of H sub(2)S by the
solid were optimised. Under the optimum conditions, predicted by the method,
each gram of ferrite was able to retain 0.274 g H sub(2)S. In addition, a
ferrite containing a known lead concentration, obtained by the precipitation
method underoptimal conditions of pH, temperature and Fe/Pb ratio, was used to
study the exothermic H sub(2)S retention reaction. The chemical reaction
occurring between the ferrite and the H sub(2)S was investigated by
characterisation of the compounds before (Pb sub(0.04)Fe super(II) sub(0.96) Fe
super(III) sub(2)O sub(4).nH sub(2)O solids composed of Pb sub(x)Fe sub(3-x)O
sub(4), magnetite Fe sub(3)O sub(4) and hydrated lead oxide PbO sub(n).H
sub(2)O) and after (PbS, PbSO sub(4), S, FeS sub(2) and alpha -FeO(OH)) the retention process.
Biological prevention and
removal of hydrogen sulphide in sludge at
Lillehammer Wastewater Treatment Plant
Einarsen, A M ; Aesoey, A ; Rasmussen, A I ; Bungum, S ; Sveberg, M
Water Science and Technology
vol. 41, no. 6 183 pp 2000
ABSTRACT: Formation of H sub(2)S and other
odorous compounds in sludge can be
prevented efficiently by controlled dosage of nitrate. Lillehammer WWTP (N) had
problems with malodour that originated mainly from the sludge treatment. High
levels of H sub(2)S caused poor working conditions, and resulted in an
overloaded hypochlorite scrubber. In addition, neighbours were complaining.
Controlled dosing was necessary to avoid increased loads on the nitrogen
removal process and floating sludge in the thickener, and to keep the H sub(2)S
concentration and chemical costs low.
This resulted in considerably better working environment and eliminated
complaints from neighbours. A cost-benefit for Nutriox registered Septicity Control has been performed.
The ability of selected chemicals for
suppressing odour development in rising mains
Hobson, J ; Yang, G
Water Science and Technology vol. 41, no. 6
183 pp. 2000
Abstract: The use of Nutriox registered and ferric chloride to suppress hydrogen
sulphide and odour generation in rising mains is evaluatd in a pilot scale
study. Without chemical dosing the hydrogen sulphide built up to the commonly
predicted levels after six months. Thereafter, addition of both Nutriox
registered and ferric chloride to sewage
entering the rising main totally suppressed the formation of H sub(2)S. Nutriox
also nearly totally suppressed the odour measured olfactometrically. The use of ferric salt at
near stoichiometric levels effectively removed dissolved sulphide. Odour
removal was generally good though on occasions reduction of dissolved sulphide
levels to below 0.1 mg/l was not guaranteed to be accompanied by near total
suppression of odour generation. The use of ferric ions at stoichiometric
levels, after H sub(2)S and odours have formed in the rising main, also eliminated the dissolved
sulphide. When used in this way, a significant residual odour potential,
110,000 ou/m super(3) remained in the sewage. The simultaneous reductions of
odour and hydrogen sulphide observed in
this study implied an apparent threshold
odour concentration of 0.1 ppb for H sub(2)S, significantly lower
than most values quoted in the
literature.
Bioscrubbing, an effective and economic
solution to odour control at wastewater
treatment plants
Hansen, N G ; Rindel, K
Water Science and Technology vol. 41, no. 6
183 pp; 2000
Abstract: Based on odour nuisances from the Damhusaaen
Wastewater Treatment Plant in Copenhagen, it was decided that the critical
sections of the inlet structure to the treatment plant should be covered and
enclosed. The ventilation air, 6000 m super(3)/h, is cleaned in a bioscrubber
process. These installations have reduced the odour in the surroundings of the
treatment plant to the extent that it is no longer noticeable. A cleaning
efficiency for hydrogen sulphide of >99% and low residual emissions, <0.1
mg/m super(3) of organic sulphur
compounds, are obtained in the bioscrubber. The consumption of the
sodium hydroxide for neutralising the sulphuric acid formed is stoichiometric
in relation to the amount of sulphur compounds removed. This results in
relatively low operating costs corresponding to half toone fourth of the
operating costs of a chemical scrubber at normal influent concentrations. In addition, the
bioscrubber has proven reliable with only little maintenance and low space
requirements. A bioscrubber can thus be considered an environment-friendly
and competitive alternative to
chemical scrubbers and biofilters.
Koe,
L C C ; Yang, F
Water Science And Technology vol. 41, no. 6
183 pp, 2000
Abstract: A study was carried out to investigate the
feasibility of using treated wastewater effluent to support the operation of a
fixed-film bioscrubber for odorous H sub(2)S removal. A laboratory scale
fixed-film bioscrubber was set up using bacteria of the genus Thiobacillus. The
bacteria were isolated from a sample of municipal sludge, cultured in the
laboratory and immobilised onto the scrubber's plastic packing media by an
immersion method. Series of experimental runs were carried out to determine the
optimal operational conditions for the bioscrubber. Results indicated that for
the gas retention times equal to or exceeding five seconds, and with a H
sub(2)S loading rate below 90 g-H
sub(2)S/m super(3)-hr, the bioscrubber could remove H sub(2)S and odour with
efficiencies greater than 99%. The behaviour of the bio-scrubber under various operation
scenarios are presented and discussed
in this paper.
Parsons, S A ; Smith, N ; Gostelow, P ;
Wishart, J
Water Science And Technology vol. 41, no. 6
183 pp, 2000
Abstract: Sewage treatment works are subject to a range of
parameters governing the quality of
effluent and sludge produced. An additional
product from treatment plants is odorous air. The causes, source, formation and measurement of odour are widely
reported and reasonably
understood. An important factor in the design
and management of works is the prediction of such odours. The importance of
this work is explained by the possibility of future legislation controlling
odour at wastewater plants. Odour dispersion modelling involves the
on-site measurement or prediction of the
emission rate of an odorous compound,
often hydrogen sulphide, and the subsequent prediction of the
atmospheric concentrations of that compound downwind of the source. This paper
used the USEPA models SCREEN3 and ISCST to determine hydrogen sulphide contour concentrations
emitted from unit processes at two different sewage treatment works in the
United Kingdom. Results indicated that the first site, located in an urban
catchment, emitted hydrogen sulphide at varying rates. The predicted downwind
concentrations using "urban" dispersion coefficients correlated well
with measured concentrations. At the second site, emission rates were less
variable. Results from the second site produced the best correlation using
"rural" dispersion coefficients. Results from both sites suggest that
the definition of the surrounding land use is critical in predicting odour
dispersion. The problem of determining
land use is highlighted and the importance of correct meteorology is
stressed. Both sites were predicted to be capable of producing hydrogen
sulphide concentrations at a detectable level outside the site boundary. Odour
complaints were therefore anticipated. The operational performance of a unit
treatment operation is proposed as a major influence on hydrogen sulphide
emission. The idea of a large database of expected emission rates from
individual unit treatment processes is proposed as an input for dispersion
modelling and as an aid to future design.
A review of the odour
impact component of the Tasman pulp and paper air discharge permit
Vaczi, S
Ogilvie, D
(ed )
ISBN:
1-877134-11-2
314
pp; 1997
Abstract: The investigation into the environmental
impacts of Tasman's odorous emissions, including an assessment of mitigation
options, cost the company close to $1.5 million and three years' work. An
extensive monitoring system was installed to supply meteorological data,
and olfactometry was used to measure
the odorous emissions from the mill. This
combined information provided the necessary inputs to enable dispersion
modelling to be performed successfully. The work resulted in very good
agreement between model predictions and ambient TRS monitors. Community annoyance levels were predicted
for different mitigation options using the dispersion model concentration
predictions and the dose-effect relationship between annoyance levels and the
99.5% odour concentrations. The validity of this method was verified by a
community survey of odour annoyance. It was found that hydrogen sulphide is not
contributing to the perceived intensity of the mill odour and the meteorology of the region plays a dominant
role at triggering odour complaints. A steam stripper was installed to remove
odorous compounds and methanol from a dominant odorous discharge to the aerated
lagoon treatment system.
Lens, P N L ; Visser, A ; Janssen, A J H ;
Pol, L W H ; Lettinga, G
Critical Reviews In
Environmental Science And Technology vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 41-88
1998
Abstract: Sulfate-rich wastewaters are generated by many
industrial processes that use sulfuric acid or sulfate-rich feed stocks (e.g.,
fermentation or sea food processing industry). Also, the use of reduced sulfur
compounds in industry, that is, sulfide (tanneries, kraft pulping), sulfite (sulfite pulping), or
thiosulfate (pulp bleaching, fixing of photographs), contaminates wastewaters
with sulfate. A major problem for the biological treatment of sulfate-rich
wastewaters is the production of H sub(2)S. Gaseous and dissolved sulfides
cause physical(corrosion, odor, increased effluent COD) or biological
(toxicity) constraints that may lead to process failure. H sub(2)S is generated
by sulfate-reducing bacteria, in both anaerobic and aerobic (anoxic
microenvironments) wastewater treatment systems. No practical methods
exist to prevent
sulfate reduction. Selective inhibition of SRB by molybdate, transition
elements, or antibiotics is unsuccessful at full scale. Selection of a treatment
strategy for a sulfate-rich wastewater depends on the aim of the treatment.
This can be (1) removal of organic matter, (2) removal of sulfate, or (3)
removal of both. Theoretically, wastewaters with a COD/sulfate ratio of 0.67 or
higher contain enough COD (electron donor) to remove all sulfate by
sulfate-reducing bacteria. If the ratio is lower, addition of extra COD, for
example, as ethanol or synthesis gas (a mixture of H sub(2), CO sub(2), and CO)
is required. Complete COD removal in wastewaters with a COD/sulfate ratio of
above 0.67 also requires
methanogenic COD
degradation. Methods to reduce sulfide toxicity and to allow optimal COD
removal are presented. Sulfate can be removed from the wastestream by the
coupling of asulfide oxidation step to the sulfate reduction step. Sulfur can
be recovered from the wastewater in case H sub(2)S is partially oxidizedto
insoluble elemental sulfur.
Effect of
distillery effluent on the dissolved organic matter, hydrogen sulfide and salinity of channel water
Boominathan, R ; Khan, S M M N
environment and ecology vol. 13, no. 1, pp.
52-55, 1995
Abstract: The present study deals with the level and effect of
dissolved organic matter, hydrogen sulfide and salinity in Uyyakondan channel
water before and after the dissolution of distillery effluent from nearby
distillery. The three parameters obviously increased after the
entry of effluent which put adverse effects
on the ecosystem.
Evaluation of chemicals to control the
generation of malodorous hydrogen sulfide in
waste water
Tomar, M ; Abdullah, T H A
Water Research vol. 28, no. 12, pp.
2545-2552, 1994
Abstract: The effect of hydrogen peroxide, sodium/calcium
hypochlorite and ferrous/ferric salts on hydrogen sulfide dissolved in waste
water were investigated to establish an effective odour control system for
Kuwait Sewage Networks. The waste water samples were collected from the inlet
structure of main pumping station with pressure pipelines and analyzed for
dissolved sulfide and pH before and after addition of chemicals individually
and in combination under controlled laboratory conditions. The waste water
contained dissolved sulfide in the range of 18 to 25 mg/l and pH ranged between
7.2 and 7.8. Various concentrations of above
mentioned chemicals were tried to determine the accurate chemical
requirement for oxidation or precipitation of
dissolved sulfide in waste water. The reaction temperature was maintained at 35
degree C ( plus or minus 2 degree C), the normal temperature of waste water in Kuwait during summer. To oxidize 1 g of
sulfide 1.25, 2.0 and 1.8 g hydrogen peroxide, sodium hypochlorite and calcium
hypochlorite were required respectively. To remove 1 g of sulfide by
precipitation with ferrous sulfate and ferric salt solution, 8 g and 4 g ferrous
and ferric salt were required respectively under laboratory
investigations. A combination of sodium
hydroxide and sodium hypochlorite was also
studied to control malodorous hydrogen sulfide in waste water. The
addition of sodium hydroxide with sodium hypochlorite in waste water reduced
the demand of hypochlorite 50%. This procedure was found to be cost effective
and best suited for the warm climate of Kuwait and was implemented in the field
at a screw conveyor type lifting station with
gravity sewer pipelines. When sodium hypochlorite was injected
withoutshock loadings of sodium hydroxide 46% reduction of dissolved sulfides
was recorded and it was increased to 57% with shock loadings of sodium
hydroxide, though the quantity of sodium hypochlorite was reduced to half than the former case. Similarly, 45 and
70% reduction in the emission of gaseous hydrogen sulfide was recorded with
NaOCl injection without and with NaOH shock loading respectively. The cost
comparison of all the chemicals when applied in field is also presented.
Large Scale
Anaerobic-Aerobic Treatment of Complex Industrial WasteWater
Using Biofilm Reactors
van
Leeuwen, H L J M ; Hols, J ; Weltevrede, R ; Mulder, A ; Heijnen, J J
Gist-brocades
Water
Science and Technology WSTED4, Vol. 23, No. 7/9, p 1427-1436, 1991.
Abstract: Warm concentrated industrial wastewaters are
preferably treated in an anaerobic reactor for reasons of energy generation and
low surplus sludge production. However, there are problems to be solved in the practical application of the
technology. These problems include a low
growth rate of the microorganisms, their low settling rate process instability, and the need for after-treatment
of the noxious anaerobic effluent which often contains NH4(+) and HS(-). An investigation
was undertaken to determine the use of biomass immobilized on small suspended
carriers as a suitable means to overcome these problems.
Research at Gist-brocades, Delft, The
Netherlands, led to the construction of a full scale plant which utilized an
anaerobic pretreatment process and an aerobic posttreatment process. The
anaerobic pretreatment process used a
liquid/solid fluidized bed as the reactor. Results revealed that the anaerobic
fluidized bed system offered an
acceptable alternative in that the process enabled a good anaerobic treatment
at high loads and short liquid residence times for
a normal load. The
aerobic posttreatment system consisted of an aerobic airlift suspension
reactor. The use of this system has shown the process to be efficient for high
rate aerobic purification. High biomass concentrations and purification
capacities in a difficult wastewater
were possible to achieve.
Leonard, J P ; Haritatos, N J ; Law, D V
Chemical Engineering Progress Vol. 80, No.
10, p 57-60, October, 1984. 3 Fig, 3
Tab, 1 Ref.
Abstract: The Chevron Waste Water Treating Process (WWT) is an
economical method of treating sour water which produces high quality hydrogen
sulfide suitable for feeding a sulfur recovery unit, anhydrous ammonia suitable
for sale and stripped water suitable for reuse or discharge. The WWT process
considered consists of four main processing steps: degassing and feed storage, acid gas
stripping, ammonia stripping, ammonia purification and liquefaction. The WWT
process is flexible and versatile. The two major reasons for building a WWT
instead of a SWSfollowed by an ammonia-burning SRU are the economics of
ammonia recovery and improved SRU
operation. The economics of the WWT process
strongly depend on the amount of ammonia present in the feed. The more
ammonia in the sour water, the more incentive there is to recover it as a
valuable by-product. Separation of ammonia from the hydrogen sulfide in the WWT
has the following advantages for the SRU: elimination of ammonia-related
problems in SRU 's such as lower operating factor, plugging in condensers and seals caused by
ammonia salts, and catalyst deactivation
increased overall sulfur recoveries
and reduction in the size of SRU 's and tail gas units because ammonia
and the air needed to burn it act as diluents. As an example, consideration is
given to a refinery SRU that gets 70% of
its acid gas feed from an amine plant
with the rest coming from a sour water stripper. The gas from the sour
water stripper contains 24 metric ton/d of ammonia. Removing the ammonia from the SRU reduces the SRU feed and
combustion air flow ratesby about 45%, thus reducing the size and cost of the
SRU. The tail gas flow rate from the SRU is reduced by about 55%. Removing the
ammonia diluent from the SRU can also increase the sulfur recovery by as much
as 2%. (Baker-IVI)
Preliminary
Investigations into the Effects of Refinery
Waste Water , and the Single
Effect of its Major Pollutants on Commercially Interesting Crops
Al
Nakshabandi, G A ; Hameed, Z ; Abdulhadi, A ; Saleem, B
Progress in Water Technology Vol 12, No 3, p
109-117, 1980. 4 Fig, 2 Tab, 4 Ref.
Abstract: The effects of refinery waste water and irrigation
water containing NH3, H2S, oil, and
phenol on commercial crops were investigated. Corn, barley, alfalfa, and radish
were irrigated with solutions containing varying amounts of one of the
pollutants, or with a dilution of API separator discharge from KNCP.
Germination of the field crops was not affected by any of the pollutants however, radish germination was retarded by
100% and 75% solutions of refinery wastewater. Growth rates of radish, barley,
and corn did not differ significantly from controls under all treatments.
Alfalfa was affected.Thus, most crops tolerated the different types and
concentrations of pollutants, except for heavily polluted waste water used in
one test. (Small-FRC)
Roberts, D G M ; Banks, P A
Water and Sewage Works Vol 127, No 1, p 59,
January, 1980.
Abstract: Special problems encountered when designing
sewage systems for arid locations include foul sewage and fouled processes and
machinery. Sewage can reach a temperature of 35 deg C and quickly become
septic. Also, low per capita water
consumption makes the sewage strong and reduces flows. The resulting emission
of hydrogen sulfide can cause severe corrosion of concrete and asbestos-cement
pipes. Problems can be minimized by avoiding turbulence of the sewage or using
forced ventilation. Also, epoxy coatings can be added to the insides of precast and in-situ concrete sewers. In areas
of windblown sand, extremely efficient air filters are essential to avoid fine
particle dust problems in the system. In activated sludge processes, windblown
sand can enter moving machinery and cause increased bearing wear. Sand can also
quickly fill small treatment lagoons. Extended aeration requires high power
costs, but produces less sludge than conventional plants. (Small-FRC)
Compost Filters for H2S
Removal from Anaerobic Digestion and Rendering Exhausts
Rands, M B ; Cooper, D E ; Woo, C P ;
Fletcher, G C ; Rolfe, K A
Journal of the Water Pollution Control
Federation Vol 53, No 2, p 185-189, February, 1981. 2 Fig, 5 Tab, 5 Ref.
Abstract: The Moerewa Meat Waste Treatment Plant has had
problems with the disposal of anaerobic digester gas for the past 20 years. The
plant produces an abundance of compost from the periodic removal of sludge from
anaerobic solids, balancing tanks, and anaerobic digesters. Pilot plant compost
filters for removing waste gases were set up to examine the suitability of such
a system to remove odors, especially H2S, and to explore the possibilities of
using similar equipment as an alternative to expensive odor control methods.
Favorable pilot plant results led to the construction of full-scale compost
filter plants in 1978. By 1979, most of the problems had been overcome and the
filter was handling the full gas flow from the aerator. An analysis of the
screened compost showed it had a bulk density of 0.813 kilograms/liter, and
composition values of moisture 45.5%, nitrogen 0.81%, carbon 36.7%,
and ash 33.9%, respectively. The average pH
of the compost was 7.82, and the carbon/nitrogen ratio was 45.4. Watering was
also instituted to prevent channeling and drying out of the compost and
cracking of the retaining walls which gave rise to small leaks.
Pescod, M B ; Price, A C
Water Pollution Control Vol 80, No 1, p
17-33, 1981. 8 Fig, 9 Tab, 6 Ref.
Abstract: The concentration of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) in the
atmosphere of interceptor sewers arriving at the sewage treatment works at
Howden, Great Britain, is important due to the proximity of a lead oxide plant
which the Northumbrian Water Authority is bound by agreement to protect from
exposure to even very low ambient H2S levels. A project was undertaken to
achieve continual extraction of air from the sewers and replacement with fresh
air so that the oxygen content of the sewer atmosphere would not be a limiting
factor in reoxygenation of flowing sewage and would not contribute to the
development of H2S in the
interceptor sewers as they approached the
treatment plant. Factors which have been identified as contributing to the
natural ventilation of sewers include sewage drag, wind-across-vent extraction,
difference in temperature between sewer atmosphere and surface ambient air,
sewage rise and fall, and change in barometric pressure. A general model for
element of sewer length between one educt vent and the next, was developed and
applied to the Tyneside sewerage scheme to estimate the oxygen concentration in
the atmosphere of a range of sewer sizes. These studies allowed some of the
fundamental factors in natural ventilation to be quantified and correlated with
influencing variables. Ventilatingair flows were then calculated for the
interceptor sewers under varying meteorological conditions. A criterion has
been suggested to allow the calculation of maximum distance between educt vents
on a sewer which will prevent oxygen deficiency in the sewer atmosphere from
affecting bacterial respiration in the flowing sewage. The results have been applied in the design of natural ventilation for the
interceptor sewers on Tyneside.
Peat Biofilters
in Long-Term Experiments
for Removing Odorous Sulphur
Compounds
Hartikainen, Tarja, University of Kuopio,
Finland; Martikainen, Pertti J.;
Olkkonen, Minna; Ruuskanen, Juhani
Water Air Soil Pollut v133, n1-4, p335(14), Jan 02
Abstract: At a waste pumping station in Finland, a packed
filter bed of fibrous peat was evaluated for the removal of hydrogen sulfide,
and in the laboratory, a peat biofilter with a volume of 2 l was studied in
terms of the removal of H2S, methyl mercaptan, and dimethyl sulfide. Results
from the in situ experiment showed that the native acid peat contained
sulfur-oxidizing microbes, as oxidation of H2S occurred without any
inoculation, but better removal was achieved using a neutralized peat. The
highest S removal achieved with both neutralized and natural peat was 135
g/m3/d. When the natural peat biofilter was limed and inoculated in the
laboratory study, a Me2S removal efficiency of 95% was achieved within two weeks.
When methyl mercaptan was added to the waste gas containing Me2S, the removal
efficiency of the latter was reduced significantly, but the removal efficiency
of methyl mercaptan was 99%. When all three gases were present, removal of S
averaged 80 g/m3/d. The lifetime of the biofilter decreased with increasing gas
load.
Odor Control
of an Anaerobic Lagoon with a Biological Cover: Floating Peat Beds
Picot, B., Universite Montpellier I, France;
Paing, J.; Toffoletto, L.; Sambuco, J.
P.; Costa, R. H. R.
Water Sci Technol v44, n9, p309(8), 2001
Abstract: A floating biological cover was evaluated
for controlling odor emission from anaerobic lagoons. The biological cover
consisted of a peat bed, and the effects of adding ferric chloride and plants
to enhance the efficiency of biofiltration were considered. The study was
conducted in five laboratory-scale pond reactors. The pond reactors were found
to represent large-scale anaerobic ponds producing hydrogen sulfide. The
presence of the floating peat bed significantly reduced H2S emissions, and
emission-rate reductions were greatest in the system containing a combination
of peat, Fe, and plants. Subsequent analysis of the systems revealed that H2S
removed from the biogas was retained in the peat. The addition of ferric
chloride increased the complexation of sulfide in the peat filter and improved
H2S removal. In the system also containing aquatic ants, plant roots took up
most of the S as sulfate, thereby enhancing further the efficiency of the peat
bed.
Wu, L., Aromatrix Pte Ltd, Singapore; Loo,
Y.-Y.; Koe, L. C. C.
Water Sci Technol v44, n9, p295(5), 2001
Abstract: At a local wastewater-treatment plant in Singapore,
biotrickling filtration was used to treat hydrogen sulfide gas. The pilot-scale
biotrickling filter was operated under normal operating sewage off-gas
conditions, under high H2S loading conditions in the presence of sewage
off-gas, and under shock H2S loading conditions in the presence of sewage
off-gas. Acclimatization and immobilization of the bacteria are described.
Under normal operating conditions, the H2S removal efficiency was 90% at inlet
concentrations ranging 0.5-17.8 ppmv. As the H2S loading rate was increased
from 20 to 100 ppmv, the removal efficiency decreased to 70%. Performance
decreased further under shock loading, but recovery was observed when the H2S
concentration was reduced to 50 ppmv, and recovery was complete when the
influent concentration was reduced to 20 ppmv.
Simultaneous Activated
Sludge Wastewater Treatment and Odour
Control
Hardy, P., Cranfield University, Bedford,
Beds, UK; Burgess, J. E.; Morton,
S.;
Stuetz, R. M.
Water Sci Technol v44, n9, p189(8), 2001
Abstract: Static-vessel tests and pilot-plant experiments were
conducted toevaluate simultaneous activated-sludge wastewater treatment and
odor control. A range of different activated sludges were used, along with
different hydrogen sulfide concentrations. The origin of the activated sludge
was found to have a strong effect on the ability to absorb H2S. Best
results were obtained using an industrial
sludge, removing 100% of the inlet H2S, which may have been due to previous
biomass acclimation. Sparging 5 ppm H2S into the activated sludge did not
impact the wastewater-treatment process adversely.
Removal and
Decomposition of Malodorants
by Using Titanium
Dioxide Photocatalyst Supported
on Fiber Activated Carbon
Nozawa, M., Tokyo University of Agriculture
and Technology, Japan; Tanigawa, K.;
Hosomi, M.; Chikusa, T.; Kawada, E.
Water Sci Technol v44, n9, p127(7),2001
Abstract: A
compact deodorizing system has been developed that consists of a sheet material
comprised of titanium dioxide supported on fiber activated carbon. Results are
presented from experiments conducted to evaluate the efficacy of the system for
removing ammonia, methyl mercaptan, and hydrogen sulfide from the gas phase.
Experiments were conducted in the presence and absence of the sheet material
and UV-irradiation. Concentrations of the malodorants and the reaction products
were measured by gas detective tubes. Four different combinations of the
TiO2/fiber activated C sheet and light sources were utilized. Results showed
that NH3 and methyl mercaptan were oxidized to nitrate and sulfate,
respectively, by photocatalysts in the presence of both systems, while methyl
mercaptan was effectively decomposed with UV irradiation without the TiO2/fiber
activated C sheet. The results suggested that the decomposition characteristics
of the malodorants varied with the dominant wavelengths of the light sources.
Sweeten, John M., Texas A&M University,
Amarillo
USDA Agricultural Outlook Forum 2001,
Arlington, VA (8),Feb 22-23, 01
Abstract: Air quality problems commonly encountered in US
livestock production operations are surveyed, highlighting ammonia and hydrogen
sulfide as odorous gases of most concern. Data gaps are identified in terms of
total suspended particulate emission rates and human responses and health
effects associated with odors and particulate matter. Current federal and state
policies concerning odor and air quality control at animal feedlots are
summarized, and prospective approaches to odor control are examined. Research
and technology transfer needs are cited.
Feasibility of
Fluidized-Bed Bioreactor for
Remediating Waste Gas
Containing H2S or NH3
Chung, Ying-Chien, National Science Council,
Taipei, Taiwan; Liu, Chia-Ho; Huang, Chihpin
J Environ Sci Health-Toxic Hazard Subst
& Environ Eng vA36, n4,
p509(12),2001
Abstract: A laboratory-scale bioreactor packed separately with immobilized Pseudomonas putida and Arthrobacter oxydans was evaluated for the treatment of gaseous hydro